The judge in the Tornado Cash case delivered an oral ruling today, rejecting both the Defense’s motion to compel discovery and their motion to dismiss the charges. This represents a massive setback for the Defense, and the judge’s reasoning may not bode well for developers and projects going forward.
Defense's Motion to Compel Discovery
The Defense's motion to compel discovery sought to access a broad range of government communications, including exchanges with foreign authorities under the Mutual Legal Assistance Treaty (MLAT) and with domestic agencies like the Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC) and the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN). The Defense argued that these materials were essential to understanding the government's case and could potentially include exculpatory evidence. However, the judge emphasized that the Defense must show that the requested information is material to their case, not merely speculate on its potential usefulness.
Rejection of Defense's Arguments
The court dismissed the Defense’s arguments as speculative, noting that references to what the information "might" or "could" reveal do not meet the necessary standard for materiality. The judge found that materiality cannot be established through conjecture or vague assertions. The Defense failed to demonstrate a specific link between the requested documents and their defense strategy.
Concerns Under Brady v. Maryland
The Defense raised concerns under Brady v. Maryland, suggesting that the government might be withholding exculpatory or impeachable evidence. The court acknowledged the government's obligations under Brady but found no concrete evidence to support the Defense's claims.
Motion to Dismiss and Definition of "Money Transmitter"
The Defense's motion to dismiss centered around the definition of a "money transmitter" under the Bank Secrecy Act (BSA). The court rejected the Defense's argument that Tornado Cash did not qualify as a money transmitter, emphasizing that Tornado Cash’s role in facilitating cryptocurrency transactions fell within the statute’s scope.
First Amendment and Code
The court addressed the Defense's argument regarding the First Amendment protection of code. While code can be expressive, using code to facilitate illegal activities does not enjoy First Amendment protection. The judge focused on the conduct enabled by the code rather than the code itself.
Immunity of Tornado Cash's Smart Contracts
The judge acknowledged the issue of immutability of Tornado Cash’s smart contracts but stated that it was not a decisive factor in the current motion. The issue may play a role at trial in determining Storm’s control over the service.
In conclusion, the judge's ruling highlights the legal system's readiness to hold participants in the digital economy accountable, even amidst the challenges of applying traditional legal principles to emerging technologies like blockchain.
CFTC
How To
A rising trend in gold IRAs
The gold IRA trend is growing as investors seek ways to diversify their portfolios while protecting against inflation and other risks.
The gold IRA allows owners to invest in physical gold bullion and bars. It is tax-free and can be used by investors who aren't concerned about stocks and bond.
An investor can use a gold IRA to manage their assets and not worry about market volatility. Investors can protect themselves from inflation and other possible problems by using the gold IRA.
Investors also get the unique benefits of owning physical Gold, including its durability, portability, flexibility, and divisibility.
Additional benefits of the gold IRA include the ability to quickly pass ownership to heirs. Additionally, the IRS does not consider gold a money or a commodity.
All this means that the gold IRA is becoming increasingly popular among investors seeking a haven during financial uncertainty.
—————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————-
By: Colin Crossman
Title: The Judge's Ruling in the Tornado Cash Case: Implications for Developers and Projects
Sourced From: bitcoinmagazine.com/legal/tornado-cash-loses-motion-to-dismiss
Published Date: Fri, 27 Sep 2024 13:52:18 GMT
